Crossing the Border: A Canadian Seller's Guide to Expanding from Amazon.ca to Amazon.com

As a Canadian Amazon seller, you've conquered the Great White North. Your products are ranking well, your reviews are stellar, and you've built a sustainable business on Amazon.ca. Now you're eyeing the elephant in the room. Or rather, south of the border. The massive Amazon.com marketplace with its 300 or more million customers compared to Canada's 40 million.

But here's the catch: expanding to the U.S. isn't just about flipping a switch. Done poorly, the hidden costs, logistics nightmares, and regulatory hurdles can evaporate your margins faster than snow in July. Done strategically, it can triple your revenue while maintaining healthy profitability.

After helping dozens of Canadian sellers successfully expand into the U.S. market, I've developed this comprehensive guide to help you make the leap without sacrificing your bottom line.

Why Amazon.com? The Opportunity in Numbers

Before we dive into the "how," let's talk about the "why":

However, this opportunity comes with legitimate challenges: currency fluctuations, increased competition, complex income tax requirements, higher advertising costs, and logistics complexities.

The key is methodical preparation.

Phase 1: Financial Feasibility Analysis (Before You Spend a Dollar)

Step 1: Calculate Your True Landed Costs

Most Canadian sellers underestimate U.S. expenses. Build a comprehensive spreadsheet including:

Category	Key Components	Typical Impact
Product costs	Supplier pricing (negotiate better rates with volume commitments) Currency exchange rates (build in 3 to 5 percent buffer for CAD/USD fluctuations) Shipping to U.S. fulfillment centers Import duties and tariffs (use the U.S. Harmonized Tariff Schedule)	20 to 30 percent of total landed cost
Amazon fees	Referral fees (usually 15 percent but varies by category) FBA fulfillment fees (often slightly lower than Canada due to scale) Monthly storage fees (account for long term storage charges) Removal/disposal fees for unsold inventory	15 to 25 percent of sale price
U.S. specific costs	Cross border accountant familiar with U.S./Canada tax treaties ($200 to 800/month) U.S. business bank account fees (if applicable) Potential U.S. corporate income tax (depending on structure and revenue thresholds) Increased PPC costs (typically 40 to 70 percent higher CPCs than Canada)	5 to 10 percent additional overhead

Step 2: Project Realistic Margins

A healthy Canadian margin of 30 percent can quickly drop to 15 to 18 percent in the U.S. after accounting for higher advertising costs and additional fees. Run scenarios with different price points:

• Scenario A: Maintain Canadian pricing (in USD) equals more competitive but lower margin
• Scenario B: Increase price 10 to 15 percent equals better margin but potentially reduced conversion
• Scenario C: Launch with aggressive pricing, plan to raise prices once reviews accumulate

Phase 2: Legal and Tax Infrastructure

Step 3: Choose Your Business Structure

You have three main options:

Step 4: Understanding U.S. Tax Obligations for Canadian Sellers

This is where many Canadian sellers get confused or receive poor advice. Let's clarify the actual requirements:

Sales Tax: Amazon Handles This

The good news: You do NOT need to register for, collect, or remit sales tax in the U.S.

Since the 2018 South Dakota v. Wayfair Supreme Court decision and subsequent legislation, Amazon collects and remits all marketplace facilitator sales tax on your behalf in all states that have such laws (which is now virtually all states with sales tax).

This is automatic when you sell through Amazon FBA or when Amazon facilitates the sale. You don't need to:

• Register for sales tax permits in any U.S. states
• Collect sales tax from customers (Amazon does this)
• File sales tax returns (Amazon handles this)
• Pay for sales tax compliance services for your Amazon sales

Exception: If you make direct sales to U.S. customers outside of Amazon (your own website, other platforms), you may have sales tax obligations. But for Amazon.com sales, this is handled entirely by Amazon.

Important: Do NOT let accountants or consultants unfamiliar with Amazon's marketplace facilitator status charge you for unnecessary sales tax registrations or compliance services for your Amazon sales.

Income Tax: Your Real Concern

Your actual tax obligations relate to income tax, not sales tax. Here's what Canadian corporations need to know:

U.S. Federal Income Tax Considerations:

1. The U.S. Trade or Business Test

• Simply selling products to U.S. customers through Amazon does NOT automatically create a U.S. taxable presence
• The IRS distinguishes between "engaged in U.S. trade or business" vs. "selling to U.S. customers"
• Key factors: Do you have employees, offices, inventory you own, or dependent agents in the U.S.?

2. The FBA Safe Harbor (Your Protection)

• In 2015, the IRS issued guidance that storing inventory in Amazon FBA warehouses does NOT, by itself, create a permanent establishment (taxable presence)
• This means FBA inventory alone doesn't trigger U.S. corporate income tax obligations
• Amazon acts as an independent agent, not a dependent agent

3. When U.S. Income Tax Obligations Trigger:

You likely need to file U.S. tax returns and potentially pay U.S. income tax if:

• You form a U.S. LLC or corporation
• You have employees or contractors performing services in the U.S.
• You have a U.S. office or physical location
• Your annual U.S. revenue exceeds certain thresholds and you're deemed to be conducting business in the U.S.
• You own inventory outside of FBA (like at a 3PL warehouse where you maintain control)

4. The Canada U.S. Tax Treaty

Canada and the U.S. have a tax treaty that prevents double taxation:

• If you do pay U.S. tax, you generally receive foreign tax credits in Canada
• The treaty provides protections for businesses without permanent establishment
• Article V defines permanent establishment (FBA typically doesn't qualify)
• Your Canadian accountant should claim treaty benefits if applicable

5. Practical Guidance for Most Canadian Sellers:

If you're a small to medium seller (under $1 to 2M USD annually) using only FBA:

• You likely don't have U.S. income tax filing requirements
• Report your U.S. income on your Canadian corporate tax return (it's still taxable in Canada)
• Keep detailed records of your business activities
• No permanent establishment means no U.S. tax

If you're a larger seller or have U.S. operations:

• Consult with a cross border tax accountant (CPA in both countries or Canadian CPA with U.S. expertise)
• You may need to file Form 1120 F (U.S. Income Tax Return of a Foreign Corporation)
• Consider whether a U.S. entity makes sense for your situation
• Potential state income tax considerations in states where you have nexus

If you form a U.S. LLC:

• Your U.S. LLC will need to file tax returns (1065 if partnership, or state returns)
• Depending on classification, may need to file informational returns
• More complexity, but may be justified for large operations

Step 5: Setting Up Your Tax Compliance (Realistically)

Here's your actual action plan:

Timeline	Actions
Before launch	Get EIN, hire accountant, set up bookkeeping
Throughout year	Track income and expenses by marketplace
Year end	Accountant assesses if you have U.S. filing requirements
Tax season	File Canadian return including U.S. income; file U.S. return only if required

Phase 3: Logistics and Inventory Strategy

Step 6: Optimize Your Cross Border Shipping

This is where most margin erosion happens. Here are three approaches:

Step 7: Inventory Management Across Borders

Inventory mistakes destroy margins through long term storage fees, stockouts, and discounting. Follow this framework:

Phase 4: Amazon Account Setup and Product Launch

Step 8: Set Up Your Amazon.com Seller Account

Critical decision: Link accounts or keep separate?

Step 9: Optimize Your Product Listings for the U.S. Market

Don't just copy paste your Canadian listings. American buyers have different search behaviors and preferences:

Step 10: Strategic Launch Plan (The Margin Safe Approach)

Traditional aggressive launches (heavy PPC, deep discounts, giveaways) can work but destroy margins initially. Here's a sustainable approach:

Phase 5: Advertising Without Bleeding Money

Step 11: Build a Margin Conscious PPC Strategy

U.S. PPC costs are significantly higher than Canada. Here's how to stay profitable:

Step 12: Organic Ranking Strategies (Free Traffic Equals Best Margins)

PPC gets you started, but organic ranking delivers sustainable margins:

Phase 6: Protecting Your Margins Long Term

Step 13: Monitor and Adjust for Profitability

Set up monthly margin audits:

Step 14: Scale What Works, Cut What Doesn't

After 6 months in the U.S. market:

Common Margin Killers and How to Avoid Them

1. Currency fluctuation neglect
   • Problem: CAD/USD swings of 5 to 10 percent can erase margins
   • Solution: Use forward contracts or currency hedging for large inventory purchases; price products with 3 to 5 percent currency buffer
2. Underestimating returns
   • Problem: U.S. return rates often 2 to 3x higher than Canada
   • Solution: Factor 8 to 12 percent return rate into pricing; improve listing to reduce buyer confusion
3. Aggressive discounting addiction
   • Problem: Using coupons and deals to maintain sales velocity destroys margins
   • Solution: Discount maximum 15 percent and only strategically; focus on organic ranking and value communication
4. Inventory management failures
   • Problem: Long term storage fees, disposal costs, or chronic stockouts
   • Solution: Implement robust forecasting; set calendar reminders for 270 day inventory age audits
5. PPC runaway spending
   • Problem: Campaigns running 24/7 at high bids regardless of performance
   • Solution: Set campaign daily budgets at 2 to 3 percent of daily revenue targets; review search terms weekly; use negative keywords aggressively
6. Ignoring product market fit
   • Problem: Products that work in Canada don't always resonate in U.S.
   • Solution: Research U.S. competition thoroughly; be willing to pivot or discontinue quickly
7. Paying for unnecessary tax compliance
   • Problem: Accountants charging for sales tax registrations and filings you don't need
   • Solution: Confirm your accountant understands marketplace facilitator laws; you should NOT be paying for 50 state sales tax compliance
8. Using the wrong tools for your business
   • Problem: Paying for expensive software with features you don't need, or using inadequate tools that miss critical data
   • Solution: Assess your specific needs (inventory management? PPC optimization? Profitability tracking?) and choose tools that excel in those areas

Real World Case Study: From $15K/Month CAD to $100K/Month USD

One of my clients, a home goods seller, followed this exact framework:

Your 90 Day Action Plan

Busting Common Tax Myths for Canadian Amazon Sellers

Let me address the biggest misconceptions I hear:

Final Thoughts: Growing Without Gambling

Expanding from Amazon.ca to Amazon.com is one of the highest ROI growth strategies available to Canadian sellers, but it requires discipline. The sellers who succeed are those who:

1. Treat it as a business expansion, not a sales experiment, proper infrastructure, legal setup, and tracking from day one
2. Protect margins religiously, more revenue means nothing if profit decreases
3. Start conservative, scale proven winners, test with limited inventory and budget
4. Accept that success takes 6 to 12 months, quick wins usually mean thin margins
5. Continuously optimize, the U.S. market is dynamic; what works today needs adjustment tomorrow
6. Work with knowledgeable advisors, a cross border accountant who understands e commerce and Amazon specifically will save you thousands in unnecessary compliance costs
7. Choose the right tools, not the most expensive or most popular, but the ones that solve YOUR specific challenges

The U.S. market is both your biggest opportunity and your fastest path to financial trouble if approached carelessly. Follow this framework, track your numbers obsessively, and be willing to move slowly at first.

Remember: It's better to profitably sell $50,000/month than unprofitably sell $200,000/month. Margin first, scale second.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

Expanding to Amazon.com is a significant decision with many moving parts. Tax implications, logistics strategies, software selection, inventory management, and margin protection. Every seller's situation is unique based on:

• Your current revenue and margin structure
• Your product category and competition level
• Your supply chain setup
• Your business entity structure
• Your risk tolerance and growth goals

While this guide provides a comprehensive framework, the details matter enormously. A single mistake in your expansion strategy can cost you thousands in lost margins, while the right approach can multiply your profits.

---